Tales Matta.
Chapter 10 of 10 FIFA has more members than the UN. And that is a map of power

10. Conclusion

The answer to the research question that opened this piece: the gap between 211 and 193 is not the result of a single logic, it is the overlap of three. Most of the divergence is institutional inheritance from whoever organised football first, before any rule shut the door (H2). A small, politically charged fraction of the divergence reflects real demand for low-cost symbolic recognition, more visible the more contested the national identity at stake (H1). And the system is not a passive conveyor belt: whoever decides who gets in, who gets out, and who is kept out applies its own criteria, selectively and sometimes reversibly within months (H3).

This piece’s contribution was to reconstruct twelve verified cases of this divergence, correct claims that circulated imprecisely in popular coverage of the topic, and test three competing explanations instead of assuming the most cited one (low-cost recognition) as self-evident. The fullest explanation is not any of the three alone: it is the sum of the three, with different weights in different cases.

A question remains that this piece does not resolve and that future work should pursue: if institutional self-interest (H3) weighs as much as the Zanzibar and Western Sahara evidence suggests, what explains FIFA accepting the political risk of admitting Kosovo in 2016, knowing Russia would react badly? The most likely answer, which this piece suggests without being able to prove it, is that FIFA’s self-interest calculation is not fixed: it changes depending on who holds power within the body, and the post-2015 era (post-corruption-scandal, under new management) may have shifted the organisation’s appetite for politically risky votes in a way the Blatter era did not allow.

References

  1. Anderson, B. (1983). Imagined Communities: Reflections on the Origin and Spread of Nationalism. Verso.
  2. Convenção de Montevidéu sobre Direitos e Deveres dos Estados (1933). Texto integral, Avalon Project, Yale Law School.
  3. Menary, S. (2007). Outcasts! The Lands That FIFA Forgot. Know the Score Books.
  4. Murray, S. (2018). Sports Diplomacy: Origins, Theory and Practice. Routledge.
  5. Nye, J. S. (2004). Soft Power: The Means to Success in World Politics. PublicAffairs.
  6. Weber, M. (1919). Politik als Beruf [A política como vocação]. Conferência, Munique.
  7. Jennings, A. (2006). Foul! The Secret World of FIFA: Bribes, Vote Rigging and Ticket Scandals. HarperSport.
  8. Sugden, J., & Tomlinson, A. (1998). FIFA and the Contest for World Football. Polity Press.
  9. Pieth, M. (Ed.). (2014). Governing FIFA: Concept Paper and Report. Independent Governance Committee.
  10. FIFA (2022). FIFA Statutes. Edição vigente, artigo sobre elegibilidade de membros.
  11. FIFA (2016). Statement on CAS decision concerning Gibraltar. Comunicado oficial, 2 mai 2016.
  12. FIFA (2016). 66th FIFA Congress, Mexico City 2016. Registro oficial do Congresso.
  13. FIFA / UEFA (2022). FIFA/UEFA suspend Russian clubs and national teams from all competitions. Comunicado oficial, 28 fev 2022.
  14. Brasil (2012). Lei nº 12.663, de 5 de junho de 2012 (Lei Geral da Copa). Presidência da República.
  15. FIFA.com. Torkil Nielsen: Two historic goals from a chess maestro. Perfil histórico oficial.
  16. Balkan Insight (2016). Friday 13th Lucky Day for Kosovo. 14 mai 2016.
  17. The New Arab (2023). How Palestine became a FIFA member after decades of neglect.
  18. United Nations General Assembly Resolution 67/19 (2012). Status of Palestine in the United Nations.
  19. Mission Permanente de Monaco auprès des Nations Unies. Monaco and the UN.
  20. The IFAB. Organisation and voting structure. Página oficial.
  21. NPR (2012). Football To Fight Against War: South Sudan Joins FIFA. 25 mai 2012.
  22. UEFA.com (2013). Landmark arrangement for Cyprus. 5 nov 2013.
  23. Hürriyet Daily News (2013). Cypriot football unified with historic deal.
  24. Morocco World News (2021). CAF Passes Amendment, Western Sahara Politics To Remain Off the Pitch.
  25. Africanews (2017). Zanzibar kicked out of CAF amid new statutes. 22 jul 2017.
  26. Inside the Games (2017). CAF installs age limit for officials as Zanzibar dismissed from organisation at General Assembly.
  27. EJIL:Talk! (2025). Greenland's Application for Membership to the International Football Community.
  28. Hasta el Gol Siempre (2009). International friendly: Catalonia 4-2 Argentina. 23 dez 2009.
  29. Goal.com (2009). Catalunya 4-2 Argentina: goals galore at the Camp Nou.
← Previous chapter9. Limitations End of analysisAll analysis →
← All analysis Get it every week